Royal Navy

HMS Impulsive (D11): Minelayer, Dunkirk Rescuer, and the Destroyer That Sank U-457

24 October 2026 · 8 min read
HMS Impulsive (D11) I-class destroyer side-on from the port side in dark wartime paint
HMS Impulsive (D11) in her dark wartime paint some time between 1940 and 1945, seen side-on from the port side, with gear crowded along the low quarterdeck where her mines were carried. Available as a restored photo print.

Built at Cowes, Built to Lay Mines

HMS Impulsive was ordered in October 1935 from J. Samuel White at Cowes on the Isle of Wight, laid down in January 1936 and launched on 1 March 1937.

She cost £258,965 to build, not counting the guns, wireless and other equipment the Admiralty supplied itself, and she was completed in January 1938 under Lieutenant Commander William Scott Thomas, who took her into the war and kept her until January 1942. No ship of the Royal Navy had carried the name before her.

She was one of the I class, the last of the pre-war run of destroyers that had begun with the A class in 1930, and the I class had a peculiarity: they were designed so that their after torpedo tubes and guns could be landed and mine rails fitted in their place, turning each of them into a fast minelayer in a matter of days.

The photograph at the top of this page shows her low quarterdeck cluttered with gear, which is where the mines went.

The First Year: Mines

The war found her in the Mediterranean with the 3rd Destroyer Flotilla. She was brought home at once, and on 14 September 1939 she started anti-submarine work in the South Western Approaches as one of the destroyers screening the carrier Courageous, which was being used, in the thinking of the time, to hunt U-boats with her aircraft.

On the evening of the 16th Impulsive attacked a sonar contact that turned out not to be a submarine. The next evening, with two of the screen away chasing another report, U-29 put two torpedoes into the carrier and she sank in about twenty minutes, taking 519 of her men with her.

Impulsive spent the night picking survivors out of the water alongside three merchant ships that had come to help, the Collingsworth, the Dido and the Dutch liner Veendam. It was the first major British warship lost in the war, and it ended the idea of using fleet carriers to hunt submarines. The view from the rest of the screen is in HMS Ivanhoe (D16).

The autumn was spent with the Home Fleet in the search for the American freighter City of Flint, which a German raider had captured, in the sortie after the armed merchant cruiser Rawalpindi was sunk by Scharnhorst and Gneisenau in November, and escorting the first Canadian troop convoy across in December.

In December she was named for the 20th Destroyer Flotilla, the minelaying destroyers, and after escorting the mined battleship HMS Nelson (28) into Portsmouth and towing the destroyer Duncan into Rosyth after a collision, she went into Portsmouth dockyard in January 1940 and came out a minelayer. From Immingham on the Humber she laid her first field in the Heligoland Bight in March.

In April 1940 she was in Operation Wilfred, the British mining of the Vest Fjord leading to Narvik, which was laid in the last hours before the Germans invaded Norway. She covered the landings at Åndalsnes later that month and on 29 April laid a field off Trondheim.

Through May she was laying the East Coast Barrier, the great belt of mines meant to keep U-boats and surface raiders off the coastal convoy route, with the auxiliary minelayer Princess Victoria, and she had just been detached when Princess Victoria was blown up by a German mine in the mouth of the Humber.

Dunkirk

On 27 May she was sent to Dunkirk. She made four crossings over the next four days, two of them on 31 May alone, under bombing, shelling and the constant risk of collision in a crowded harbour, and she brought home about 2,900 soldiers of the British Expeditionary Force.

On 1 June her propellers were damaged and she was withdrawn, and she was patched up at Blackwall on the Thames in time to be back at Immingham by midsummer.

She went straight back to minelaying. In August she was away boiler cleaning on the Tyne and so missed Operation CBX, the Dutch coast minelay of 31 August in which three of the flotilla ran into a German minefield off the Texel. Esk and Ivanhoe were sunk and Express had her bow blown off.

That disaster is told in Ivanhoe's article. In September, with invasion expected any night, Impulsive was laying mines in the Dover Strait.

A Liner's Survivors, and the First Convoy to Russia

Through the winter of 1940 and into 1941 she laid fields in the Channel from Plymouth and Portsmouth, off Cap d'Antifer and on the approaches the Germans might use. In May 1941 she landed 278 survivors of the armed merchant cruiser Salopian, torpedoed in the North Atlantic, at Greenock.

The minelaying flotilla was disbanded that month, and after one more lay in the Northern Barrage between Scotland and Iceland, she became a fleet destroyer again with the 3rd Flotilla.

At the end of September 1941 she escorted PQ 1, one of the first convoys to the Soviet Union, from Iceland to North Russia, and came home in company with the cruiser Suffolk. It was the start of a route she would come to know very well.

PQ 18 and U-457

After a refit at Southampton she rejoined the Home Fleet in the summer of 1942, the summer of PQ 17, when a convoy was ordered to scatter and was cut to pieces. The next one, PQ 18, sailed in September with a far larger escort, including an escort carrier and a "fighting destroyer escort" of sixteen fleet destroyers whose job was to stay with the convoy and fight. Impulsive was one of them.

PQ 18 was attacked by waves of torpedo bombers and by a pack of U-boats for days on end. In the early hours of 16 September, deep in the Barents Sea west of Novaya Zemlya, U-457 tried to get in at the convoy.

Impulsive, now under Lieutenant Commander Edward Roper, picked her up on sonar at under eight hundred metres, ran in and dropped five depth charges. Oil and wreckage came up. Captain Karl Brandenburg and all forty-five of his crew were lost.

Two days earlier U-457 had torpedoed the tanker Atheltemplar in the same convoy.

Detached the next day to the homeward convoy QP 14, Impulsive and Fury went off to Spitsbergen to bring in the tanker Oligarch, and she spent the rest of the autumn on the Russian route.

The Atlantic, the Arctic and Normandy

In March 1943 she was sent to the Western Approaches with the 3rd Support Group, Offa, Penn and Panther, and in late April and early May fought through the battle round the convoys ONS 5 and SC 128 against two U-boat packs at once, the action that turned the Battle of the Atlantic. HMS Offa (G29) has her own article. By the winter she was back in the Arctic with JW 54A, JW 55B and their returns.

In the spring of 1944 the flotilla was taken south for the invasion. On 6 June she was off Sword Beach giving gunfire support to the troops going ashore, and for the rest of June she patrolled the eastern flank of the anchorage and escorted the convoys across.

After a refit at Immingham she spent the last winter of the war with an escort group in the South Western Approaches, hunting the schnorkel U-boats that had come back into British coastal waters.

The King and the Channel Islands

In March 1945 she joined the 8th Destroyer Flotilla at Portsmouth for Channel convoy work, and her last weeks of service were happy ones. On 14 May, five days after the Channel Islands were freed, she visited St Peter Port in Guernsey.

On 7 June she was in the escort when the cruiser HMS Jamaica (44) carried King George VI and Queen Elizabeth to the Islands to visit the people who had lived under German occupation for five years.

Ten days later, on 17 June 1945, she was reduced to reserve at Harwich. She was put on the disposal list that year, sold for scrap, and arrived at Sunderland under tow on 22 January 1946 to be broken up.

Six Battle Honours

Her battle honours were Norway 1940, Dunkirk 1940, Arctic 1941-44, Atlantic 1942-43, Normandy 1944 and English Channel 1944, and they are a fair summary of the whole naval war in home waters.

She was built by a yard on the Isle of Wight a few miles from where these prints are made, she spent her first year laying mines and her last in the Channel, and in between she went everywhere the Home Fleet's destroyers went and got out of almost all of it in one piece.

Follow @Hantsprints on X for more Royal Navy history and warship, submarine and shore establishment photography.
Follow on X

The print featured in this article

Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.

HMS Impulsive D11 I Class Destroyer 1940 to 1945
HMS Impulsive D11 I Class Destroyer 1940 to 1945 Photo Print from £4.00 See sizes and prices

Leave a comment

Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Written by
Lee Edwards

Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.

More about Lee