HMS Stubborn (P238): Towing X7 to the Tirpitz and Surviving Five Hundred Feet Off Norway
A Mule's Head on the Mersey
HMS Stubborn was ordered from Cammell Laird of Birkenhead on 25 January 1941, one of the third group of S Class submarines. She was laid down on 10 September 1941 and launched on 11 November 1942, and on 18 February 1943 she left the builder's yard for the Clyde.
Two days later she ran her speed trials over the measured mile off Arran and was commissioned at Holy Loch. Her badge, approved in May 1943, was a mule's head, the most stubborn of animals, with the motto Fortiter in re, "bravely in action". She is the only ship of the Royal Navy to have carried the name.
Her captain was Lieutenant Arthur Duff, who had stood by her while she was fitting out. The photograph was taken in February 1943 by the Liverpool firm of Stewart Bale, and shows her on the surface in choppy grey water with merchant ships lying at anchor behind her.
Within a week of commissioning she was out searching the Clyde for her missing sister boat Vandal, which had disappeared on exercises and would not be found until 1994.
Three U-Boats in the Bay of Biscay
Stubborn's first patrols, from Lerwick in the spring of 1943, took her off the Lofoten Islands and then far north to Jan Mayen and across the Norwegian Sea, hunting U-boats on passage to and from the Atlantic. In June she was sent south to the Bay of Biscay, and at dawn on 2 July, in the morning haze, she sighted two large German destroyers heading east.
Behind them, in line, were three U-boats. Duff fired six torpedoes at the last of them from a thousand yards. All six missed, and the Germans never knew they had been attacked. The destroyers were Z24 and Z32, sent out to escort U-180 into Bordeaux.
U-180 was on her way home from the Far East with a valuable cargo, and the other two boats, U-518 and U-530, had joined the escort on the way in.
Operation Source
In September 1943 Stubborn was one of six submarines chosen to tow the new X-craft midget submarines across the North Sea for Operation Source, the attack on the German battleship Tirpitz and her consorts in the fjords of northern Norway. She sailed from Loch Cairnbawn on 11 September with X7 on a tow line astern of her and X7's passage crew on board the midget.
The tow parted on 15 September and had to be repaired, and that afternoon she came across X8, which had broken away from her own towing submarine, Sea Nymph; Stubborn stood by and signalled until Sea Nymph found her charge again. On 18 September the operational crew of X7, under Lieutenant Godfrey Place, went across to take over the midget for the attack, and the tow parted once more as Stubborn got under way.
The strangest moment came in the early hours of 20 September. A floating mine was sighted ahead, and before it could be avoided it caught on the tow line and began to slide slowly down the wire towards X7. It lodged on the midget's bow, where Place, standing on the casing, pushed it clear with his foot.
That evening X7 slipped her tow and headed in towards Soroy Sound, and two days later Place laid his charges beneath the Tirpitz, crippling her for months and winning the Victoria Cross. He and one of his crew were taken prisoner; the other two were lost.
Stubborn waited out at sea, and on 28 September she found X10, under the Australian Lieutenant Ken Hudspeth, which had been towed over by Sceptre but had been unable to make her attack and was making her way back out. Stubborn took her in tow, but on 3 October a gale warning came through and X10 had to be scuttled.
Off Namsos, February 1944
Through the winter Stubborn patrolled the inshore convoy route off Kya, on the coast of central Norway, missing a convoy in December and a single ship, the Kong Dag, in January. On 11 February 1944 she found a convoy of seven merchant ships with five escorts and an aircraft overhead about twenty-five miles north-west of Namsos, and fired six torpedoes.
She sank the German steamer Makki Faulbaums of 1,907 tons and damaged the Norwegian Felix, which was in German hands, and went deep for a counter-attack of thirty-four depth charges, which she survived without harm.
Two days later, off the Folda Fjord, she attacked again. This time all six torpedoes missed, and a German minesweeper picked her up on its asdic. In a quarter of an hour it dropped thirty-six depth charges, all very close.
Her after hydroplanes jammed hard to dive, one of her tanks flooded, the starboard propeller was fouled and smoke began to pour from the main motor, which was stopped at once. Stubborn sank to 390 feet, well below the 350 feet her class was designed for, before blowing her main ballast checked her.
For the next hour she hung between two and three hundred feet while her crew tried to hold a trim by moving men from one end of the boat to the other. At ten past one she broke surface. No one saw her, but when she dived again she went down fast and stopped only at five hundred feet.
Shortly before three o'clock she broke surface a second time, with the minesweeper a mile and a half away, and dived once more. Again she plunged, and this time blowing her tanks did not stop her. She struck the seabed and bumped along it four times, while three more patterns of depth charges exploded close by.
Her crew lay on the bottom until it was dark. The first attempt to surface failed, and it was not until half past ten at night, after running the compressors to build up air, that she finally came up.
A Destroyer Seen Bows-On
She was in a bad way. The port propeller seemed to have lost half its blades, the hull was distorted and vibrating, plates were bulging between the frames of the pressure hull, the steering gear was labouring and the starboard motor was out of action.
At about seven knots she could not dive with any confidence, so Duff decided he would not dive at all, even if aircraft found her. Three German aircraft passed during the next day without seeing her.
That evening she stopped answering her helm, and it took until the early hours of 15 February to get a signal through to the Flag Officer Submarines. Four destroyers were sent out to find her, and on the afternoon of 16 February the first two, Musketeer and Scourge, came over the horizon.
Duff wrote in his patrol report, "I have never previously appreciated the beauty of a destroyer seen bows-on."
Getting her home was not straightforward. Scourge took her in tow on 17 February and the tow parted. Meteor and Swift joined the next day, Beaufighters circled overhead and the Norwegian destroyer Narvik came up from the west. Musketeer tried a tow on 19 February which held for sixteen minutes.
That afternoon Scourge tried again, and this time the tow held all night. On the morning of 20 February Stubborn was brought into Lerwick by the Norwegian naval vessel Molde. The repairs kept her out of the war for the rest of 1944.
The Java Sea
In 1945, under Lieutenant Albert Davies, Stubborn made a working-up patrol off south-west Norway and then sailed for the East, passing through the Suez Canal on 7 May and joining the British submarines at Fremantle in Western Australia. Her only patrol from there began on 13 July 1945.
After fuelling at Onslow she passed north through the Lombok Strait into the Java Sea, and on the evening of 25 July she fired four torpedoes at what she took to be a destroyer of the old Minekaze class. Two hit, and the ship sank quickly. She was Patrol Boat No. 2, the former destroyer Nadakaze of 1920.
Stubborn surfaced among about sixty survivors, none of whom would come aboard. The history of the boat compiled for uboat.net records that one man in the water was shot and that Davies ordered the rest to be fired on, but that an aircraft forced her to dive before it could be done; the patrol report itself says nothing of this.
When she came back up an hour later there was no one left to be seen.
On 27 July, in Saleh Bay on the island of Sumbawa, she stopped a small cutter carrying rice for a Japanese garrison, took off its crew of six and had them throw all 176 bags overboard, and destroyed a second boat with the same cargo with her gun. That evening she went alongside a junk, and her first lieutenant, Peter Jones, and Leading Seaman Kennedy went aboard to look at the cargo.
As Stubborn manoeuvred in the shallow water the junk broke adrift. Kennedy swam back, but the gap was too great for Jones. He was told by megaphone that the submarine would wait for him, and Stubborn searched through the night and all the next day, but he was never seen again.
Jones was twenty-four, came from Southsea, had married at Gosport two years before, and had earlier served as first lieutenant of Statesman. On 30 July she surfaced off Buleleng on the north coast of Bali and opened fire on a camouflaged landing craft, until a shore battery replied and she dived away.
She spent her last days of the war on lifeguard duty south of the Lombok Strait, waiting for airmen who might come down in the sea, and was back at Fremantle on 9 August, days before the Japanese surrender. Her sister Spark worked the same waters that summer.
Off Qawra Point
Stubborn left Australia on 1 October 1945 and reached Malta on 13 January 1946, where she was to be sold for scrap. Instead she was used as an asdic target, and on 30 April 1946 she was sunk off the north coast of the island.
Her wreck still sits upright on the seabed off Qawra Point, and she is now one of the best-known submarine dives in the Mediterranean.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.