HMS Thistle (N24): Lost off Norway on the Second Day of the Invasion and Found Again in 2023
A Scottish Name
HMS Thistle was ordered from Vickers-Armstrongs of Barrow on 20 July 1937, one of the first group of T Class submarines, the big ocean-going patrol boats the Royal Navy had designed in the mid-1930s with ten torpedo tubes facing forward, the heaviest bow salvo of any submarine in the world. She was laid down on 7 December 1937, launched on 25 October 1938 and commissioned on 4 July 1939.
Her badge, approved in May 1938, was simply the spear thistle, the national flower of Scotland.
The photograph was taken by the Portsmouth Dockyard's Constructive Department on 2 August 1939, as she ran through Spithead in the pale grey of the peacetime Navy with her tall wireless mast raised and guardrails rigged along her casing. Within a month the guardrails would come down and the paint would darken. Her captain was Commander Robert Stirling-Hamilton.
The First Winter
When war came she was sent round from Dover to Dundee, and on 28 September 1939 she sailed for her first patrol in the Skagerrak, the strait between Norway and Denmark. On the evening of 30 September, about thirty miles north-west of Hanstholm in Denmark, she found the Swedish steamer Gun lying stopped with her lights showing.
A small dark shape was glimpsed nearby and then lost. It was the German U-3, which had stopped the Gun and, unknown to anyone in Thistle, fired a torpedo at the British submarine as she came in to investigate. It missed. After midnight Thistle came across one of the Gun's boats making an SOS signal.
Her crew had been ordered off by the U-boat, and since their ship was still afloat Thistle told them to go back aboard.
Through that first winter she patrolled again and again in the North Sea and the Skagerrak. In November she was sent off Skagen after the German battleships sank the armed merchant cruiser Rawalpindi; at Christmas she was waiting there for the pocket battleship Deutschland, which was believed to be at sea; in January she rode out heavy weather and saw nothing.
In February 1940 Lieutenant-Commander Wilfrid Haselfoot took command. In March she lay off southern Norway in Operation R.3, waiting for orders to break into the Baltic to help the Finns against the Soviet Union, until Finland signed an armistice a few hours after she sailed and the operation was called off.
The smaller S Class submarine Sterlet was also in the Skagerrak that spring and was lost there days after Thistle.
Six Torpedoes off Stavanger
In the first days of April 1940 the British submarines were spread across the approaches to Norway, expecting a German move. On 8 April Thistle met the submarine Clyde on the surface before aircraft drove them both under, and that evening she was ordered to patrol off the Skudesnes Fjord, south of Haugesund.
The next day German troops landed all along the Norwegian coast and seized Stavanger and its airfield. At four o'clock that afternoon, south-west of Stavanger, Thistle fired six torpedoes at a German U-boat, U-4.
The U-boat's lookouts saw a track and turned away, and heard three explosions as the torpedoes reached the end of their run.
Haselfoot reported the attack and that he had only two torpedoes left. The Flag Officer Submarines had wanted Thistle to go into Stavanger itself and sink whatever she could find in the harbour, but with so few torpedoes her orders were changed, and she was told to stay off Skudesnes instead. No more was heard from her.
Ten Minutes Past Two
U-4 had not gone far. At three minutes to two on the morning of 10 April, German time, she sighted a submarine on the surface off Skudeneshavn, at the southern tip of the island of Karmoy, steering slowly north while she charged her batteries in the dark. It was Thistle.
At 2.13 U-4 fired a torpedo from four hundred metres and missed. She fired a second from two hundred and fifty metres, and it hit. Thistle blew up and sank at once. There were no survivors.
Fifty-three men died with her. Haselfoot was thirty-two. The youngest of the crew were twenty, and the oldest, Chief Engine Room Artificer Joseph Todd, was forty-two.
Many of them, like Chief Petty Officer Herbert Hammond and Leading Seaman Harold Simpson, belonged to the Portsmouth port division and are remembered on the Portsmouth Naval Memorial on Southsea Common; their shipmates from the Chatham and Devonport divisions are named on the memorials there.
Found in 2023
For eighty-three years no one knew exactly where she lay. In the spring of 2023 the Norwegian Institute of Marine Research, mapping the seabed off south-west Norway in its MAREANO programme, found the wreck of a submarine in about 160 to 170 metres of water off Karmoy.
A second survey that October showed a British submarine of the right type, with her conning tower blown away, close to the position U-4 had given, and no other submarine of her kind is known to have been lost there. The find was made public in October 2023 and the wreck has been accepted as Thistle.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.