HMS Unruly (P49): A Minelayer Sunk off Amorgos and the Italian Submarine That Got Away
A Leek Submarine
HMS Unruly was laid down at Vickers-Armstrongs in Barrow-in-Furness in November 1941, launched on 28 July 1942 and commissioned on 3 November that year as P49, one of the numbered U Class boats. She is the only ship of the Royal Navy to have carried the name.
Her captain, Lieutenant John Fyfe, joined her before she commissioned and stayed with her for two years, through every one of her war patrols. In Warship Week in March 1942 the Staffordshire town of Leek and its surrounding rural district had adopted her.
Norway and the South of France
P49 sailed from Lerwick two days before Christmas 1942 for her first patrol, off northern Norway in the dark of the Arctic winter, and came back in mid-January. By the spring she had joined the submarines working from Algiers, and on 12 April 1943, off Cape Béar near Port Vendres, close to the Spanish frontier, she torpedoed and sank the Danish steamer Aalborg, seized by the Germans and working for them.
A motor launch dropped some twenty depth charges in reply, but none came close. The photograph shows her coming into Algiers in April 1943, at the end of one of these patrols.
Off Sicily
Unruly then moved to Malta for the build-up to the invasion of Sicily. On 16 May she torpedoed and damaged the new transport Nicolò Tommaseo just north of Catania, hitting her in the stern while two more torpedoes passed just ahead of her escort, the torpedo boat Clio, which hunted Unruly for the rest of the day.
A few nights later, east of Augusta, she fired a full salvo at the Italian submarine Marcantonio Bragadino, returning from a supply run to Lampedusa, whose lookouts saw the tracks just in time to turn away. On 14 June, off Cape Vaticano on the Calabrian coast, she sank the transport Valentino Coda, which had sailed from Naples the day before.
As the invasion began in July she was stationed off Cape Vaticano to catch Italian submarines heading south through the Tyrrhenian Sea to attack the landing fleet.
On the evening of 13 July 1943 she sighted a southbound Italian submarine and fired four torpedoes from three thousand yards. Her crew heard what they took for a hit two minutes later, and the other three torpedoes ran on and exploded against the coast.
For many years Unruly was credited with sinking the Italian submarine Acciaio that evening, and many books still say so. Italian records tell a different story. Her target was the Benedetto Brin, whose lookouts saw the British submarine diving and turned away in time, and the Brin escaped without a scratch.
Earlier that same afternoon Unruly had carried out a dummy attack, for practice, on a passing Italian hospital ship.
Brindisi and the Adriatic
In August Unruly patrolled the approaches to Brindisi, where she watched the minesweepers and corvettes come and go, and on 15 August, barely two miles from the harbour mouth, she torpedoed and damaged the tanker Cesco. In early September she was off Durazzo on the Albanian coast when Italy surrendered.
The Dodecanese
After the Italian armistice the British tried to seize the Dodecanese islands from the Germans, and in the autumn of 1943 the submarines were sent into the Aegean to cut the German sea routes to Kos and Leros. Before dawn on 7 October, east of the island of Amorgos, Unruly found a German convoy of a small transport and a group of landing craft.
Her torpedoes missed, but she sent off a contact report in the hope of bringing British surface ships down on it, chased the convoy and damaged one of the landing craft with her gun. Within hours the convoy was caught and destroyed by the cruisers Sirius and Penelope and the destroyers Faulknor and Fury.
The next afternoon, south of Amorgos, Unruly was given an aircraft report of an enemy ship coming towards her. It was the German auxiliary minelayer Bulgaria, loaded with supplies and soldiers for Kos, in company with the minelayer Drache.
Fyfe fired four torpedoes from 1,350 yards and one hit; the Bulgaria went down at once, and Unruly sat out the depth charges that followed in silence a hundred feet down.
A Gun War in the Aegean
By November both Kos and Leros were in German hands, and for the rest of her time in the Mediterranean Unruly fought a different kind of war among the islands, against the caiques, the wooden sailing and motor vessels that carried most of the German garrisons' supplies. In December 1943 and January 1944 she sank a string of them by gunfire, off Levitha, off Andros and north of Syros.
Twice she went into the harbour of Panormos on Tinos. On the afternoon of 11 January 1944 she watched a big, heavily laden caique enter the harbour, crept in submerged to find three caiques inside, surfaced a thousand yards off and sank all three with thirty-three rounds, and was gone again within ten minutes.
On 21 January, before heading home to Malta, she surfaced and fired the last of her three inch ammunition at a German traffic control station on the little island of Kandelioussa. She scored four hits, did little damage and, as her report put it, hoped that a few Germans had had a nasty twenty minutes.
In March 1944 she carried out Operation Crust, a deception landing on Zakynthos by a party of the Special Boat Service under Major Courtney. In April she was off Psara and Chios, finishing off caiques with gunfire and scuttling charges, and in July she made two attempts on the new German transport Pelikan, missing both times.
Home
In August 1944 Unruly was taken in hand for refit at Sheerness. John Fyfe left her that October, and she spent the last months of the war in home waters as a training boat. She was broken up at Inverkeithing in February 1946.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.