HMS Unshaken (P54): A Captain Lost Overboard, a Raid on Pantelleria and the Capture of the Ciro Menotti
From Barrow to Norway
HMS Unshaken was laid down at Vickers-Armstrongs in Barrow-in-Furness in June 1941, launched on 17 February 1942 and commissioned on 21 May 1942 as P54, one of the numbered U Class boats; the photograph, taken from the air, shows her that same month, running fast on the surface. Staines had adopted her in its Warship Week that March.
In June Lieutenant Charles Oxborrow took command. A Welshman from Maesteg, he had begun his service in the Fleet Air Arm as a rating pilot before turning to submarines.
Her first patrols were off Norway. On 12 August 1942, off the southern coast, she attacked a small convoy that had just left Kristiansand and sank the German transport Georg L.M. Russ; thirty-nine of her crew were picked up, but her master and ten others were lost.
In September she went far north, into the Arctic off the Norwegian coast.
Torch, and a Wave in the Gulf of Lions
In October P54 went south to Gibraltar for the Allied landings in North Africa. On 1 November she sailed with only six torpedoes aboard, to make room for two canoes and a party of six under Lieutenant Teacher, whose job was to mark the landing beaches off Oran for the assault craft. Afterwards she patrolled towards the south coast of France.
On the evening of 25 November 1942, in very heavy weather in the Gulf of Lions, P54 surfaced with Oxborrow and two lookouts, Yeoman of Signals Sidney Bennett and Able Seaman Charles Thorn, already on the bridge. She rolled heavily, the conning tower flooded and she slid back down to about thirty feet before the lower hatch could be shut to save the boat.
When she was brought back to the surface, all three men were gone. A search found nothing.
The temporary first lieutenant, Sub-Lieutenant Herbert Westmacott, who was standing in because the regular first lieutenant had been left sick at Gibraltar, took command and turned her for harbour, and a new captain, Lieutenant Jack Whitton, was flown out to join her by Catalina flying boat four days later.
Climene
Under Whitton, and named Unshaken from early 1943, she worked first from Algiers and then from Malta. On 8 April she sank the transport Foggia north-east of Sousse. On 28 April she had a fright when two British destroyers mistook her for an enemy and attacked; she dived and came to no harm.
Later the same day, about twenty-five miles south-west of Marettimo off western Sicily, she found the Italian torpedo boat Climene escorting two German transports from Tunis to Trapani and sank her with her torpedoes. Fifty-three of the Climene's crew died, and about ninety were picked up.
The Raid on Pantelleria
In late May 1943, with the Allies preparing to take Pantelleria before the invasion of Sicily, Unshaken carried a small raiding party to the island, an operation called Snapdragon, apparently to bring back a prisoner. On the night of 28 May they paddled ashore and climbed the cliffs, and they did seize a sentry, but he could not be silenced quickly enough and raised the alarm.
Four Italians who came running out were killed, and one of the raiders was so badly wounded that he had to be left behind. The prisoner fought so hard that he could not be got down the steep cliff, so he too was left, and the party came back to Unshaken empty handed in the early morning.
Pantelleria surrendered to the Allies after heavy bombing a fortnight later.
Sicily and Brindisi
In June Unshaken was off Augusta and Syracuse, sinking the schooner Giovanni G. and the transport Pomo, and during the invasion of Sicily in July she sank an anti-submarine schooner by gunfire off Calabria. In August she moved to the approaches to Brindisi, and on 10 August, three miles east of the port, she torpedoed the troopship Asmara on passage from Taranto to Bari.
The Asmara was beached but sank the next day; remarkably, of the 157 men aboard only one was killed and one went missing. On 5 September she damaged the tanker Dora C. off Brindisi.
The Ciro Menotti
On the evening of 8 September 1943 Unshaken received the signal to cease hostilities against Italy, whose surrender had just been announced. The next evening, leaving her patrol area in the Straits of Otranto, she heard propellers and then sighted a submarine on the surface five miles off.
Closing to attack, Whitton saw that she was Italian, not German. He surfaced and fired a single round across her bows to stop her, and the Italians answered with a burst of machine gun fire. Unshaken turned as if to fire torpedoes, the firing stopped, and the two boats came within hailing distance.
The Italian captain said he was making for Brindisi for orders. Told to steer for Malta instead, he at first refused, but with Unshaken's gun trained on him and the terms of the surrender explained, he agreed. An armed party went across, and the two submarines set off for Malta together, the Ciro Menotti in front.
She had to stop the next evening with an air lock in her fuel system, but after twenty-five minutes she was under way again, and a motor launch met them and escorted them both into Malta. The Ciro Menotti was an old opponent of the U Class: twenty months earlier HMS Unique had fired four torpedoes at her off Augusta and missed.
North Again
Unshaken patrolled off Corsica in the autumn of 1943 and then came home for refit. In January 1944 the refit was put off, because two submarines of the 9th Flotilla had been damaged, and she was made ready for service in their place.
On 7 April 1944, off Lister on the south coast of Norway, she torpedoed and sank the German transport Asien from a convoy of seven merchant ships with a strong escort; her crew were all saved. Afterwards she served as a training boat in home waters, and she was broken up at Troon in March 1946.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.