Royal Navy

HMS Utmost (N19): Cayley's Boat, the Cruiser Trieste and Saboteurs on the Calabrian Railway

15 November 2026 · 7 min read
HMS Utmost (N19) U Class submarine seen from her port side in May 1942, her pennant number painted large on the conning tower, a White Ensign above the bridge and her deck gun forward on a calm sea
HMS Utmost in May 1942, fresh from her refit, with her pennant number painted in large white letters on the conning tower and a White Ensign flying above the bridge. Her deck gun sits just forward of the bridge and jumping wires run from bow and stern to the top of the tower. Available as a restored photo print.

A Weather Vane at the Top

HMS Utmost was ordered from Vickers-Armstrongs at Barrow-in-Furness on 4 September 1939, the day after war was declared, as one of the second group of U Class submarines. She was laid down that November, launched on 20 April 1940 and commissioned at Rothesay on 17 August 1940 under Lieutenant John Eaden.

She is the only ship of the Royal Navy to have carried the name, and her badge makes a neat joke of it: a golden weather vane topped by a cockerel, since a weather vane always sits at the utmost point of a building. In Warship Week in 1942 she was adopted by Prestwich, near Manchester, where the Sedgley Park club even sent her crew a football kit.

Her adoption plaque and her Jolly Roger are now kept in Bury, and another plaque to her is in St Mary's Church, Prestwich.

Rammed by a Friend

After a first patrol from Portsmouth in the autumn of 1940, Utmost sailed for Gibraltar and the Mediterranean. On 6 November, off Cape St Vincent, the destroyer HMS Encounter took her for an enemy and rammed her.

She survived, but needed more repairs after she reached Malta in December, and it was not until February 1941, under her new captain, Lieutenant Commander Richard Cayley, that she began operating with the 10th Flotilla.

Cayley's Boat

Dick Cayley was one of the outstanding submarine captains at Malta, and with Upholder, Urge and the rest of the little U Class boats Utmost made 1941 a bad year for the Axis convoys to Libya. In February she damaged the transport Mauly off Zuwara.

On 9 March, north-east of Sousse, she hit the transport Capo Vita, which blew up with an enormous explosion that showered the other ships with debris; forty-three men were killed. The convoy had been spotted from the Tunisian coast by a watcher of the Mounier network, part of the resistance, who passed the news to Malta, and the next day HMS Unique sank another of its ships, the Fenicia.

On 28 March, south-east of Kuriat, Utmost fired four torpedoes into a convoy of German transports carrying troops and vehicles for Rommel. The Heraklea sank, taking seventy-eight of the 212 German soldiers aboard with her, and the Ruhr, with 585 soldiers, had to be towed into Trapani.

Agents for Tunisia

That April Utmost carried out a quieter kind of operation off the Gulf of Hammamet. On the night of 28 April she surfaced off the coast, met a small sailing boat manned by two members of the Mounier network, and handed over Commandant Breuillac, a French officer who was to lead a resistance group in Tunisia, together with his stores, which included limpet mines for sabotage in the harbours.

In October she landed more supplies for the same network; the canoe sank on the way back and its crew had to swim to the submarine. The network did sink a couple of ships, but one of its saboteurs was caught and talked, and it was broken up.

Trains in Calabria

In the summer of 1941 Utmost's patrols moved to the Tyrrhenian coast of Italy, where the railway from Naples to Reggio ran right along the shore. On 26 June she sank the coal ship Enrico Costa off Cape Todaro in Sicily, needing a third torpedo when the first hit failed to sink her.

On the night of 27 July, near Pizzo in the Gulf of Sant'Eufemia, she put two men ashore in a canoe, Lieutenant D.R. Schofield of the Royal Fusiliers and Lance Corporal F.C. Morgan, who laid explosives under the line. At one in the morning a big southbound train ran over the charge and the rear of it was derailed.

The next day she torpedoed and sank the small steamer Federico north-west of Paola. In August Lieutenant R. Wilson of the Royal Artillery and Marine W.G. Hughes blew up part of a railway bridge near the mouth of the river Saracena; the bridge was damaged rather than destroyed.

Two more attempts in September, on a tunnel and another bridge, were foiled when the pair were spotted. Cayley was awarded the DSO.

The Trieste

On the night of 21 November 1941, south of the Straits of Messina, Utmost was waiting for a big Italian convoy bound for Libya with a heavy escort of cruisers. Just before eleven o'clock she heard propellers and then saw three cruisers and three destroyers five miles off, steaming at twenty knots.

Cayley fired four torpedoes at the rear cruiser. One hit just behind the forward funnel, and a column of flame shot more than two hundred feet into the air, lighting up the sea for miles. Utmost dived and slipped away as eighty-four depth charges were dropped behind her.

The ship she had hit was the heavy cruiser Trieste. Twenty-two of her men were killed, she shipped some three thousand tons of water, and she was out of action until the middle of July 1942. The convoy was turned back to Taranto.

Refit and Return

Utmost came home in January 1942, and her crew were photographed with their Jolly Roger before she was refitted at Blyth from February to April; the photograph was taken in May, soon after she came out of dockyard hands. Cayley left her, and was lost early the next year in command of the new submarine P311.

Utmost went back to Malta in June 1942 under Lieutenant Anthony Langridge, and in September Lieutenant John Coombe took command. On the night of 9 October, in an operation called Blackbird, she landed two Italian agents near Naples for the Special Operations Executive.

They were the Zaccaria brothers, determined opponents of Mussolini whose father had died in a concentration camp, and they were caught soon after landing; both were shot in Rome on 10 November 1942. A few days later Utmost torpedoed and sank the tanker Nautilus off Cape Figari in Sardinia.

Lost off Sicily

In November 1942, with the Allies landing in North Africa, Utmost fired at an Italian submarine and at a cruiser force off Augusta without success. On 23 November, three miles north of Cape Blanc near Bizerta, she fired her last torpedoes at the auxiliary minelayer Barletta, which saw the tracks and turned away.

Utmost signalled that she had made a successful attack, was out of torpedoes and was coming home. She would cross the minefield to the south-west of Sicily submerged in daylight on the 24th, and expected to reach the end of the Malta swept channel on the morning of the 25th. She never arrived.

Her loss has never been explained for certain. Rome Radio claimed on the 24th that an Allied submarine had been sunk, and on the 25th the Italian torpedo boat Groppo, escorting a convoy west of Sicily, hunted an echo and claimed a kill, which is the explanation given in many accounts.

But the Italian navy's own analysis judged Groppo's claims doubtful, and the position and timing fit poorly with Utmost's own signal. The likeliest answer is that she struck a mine on her way home through the minefield.

Thirty-three men were lost with her, and she remains one of the many submarines of the 10th Flotilla with no known grave.

Follow @Hantsprints on X for more Royal Navy history and warship, submarine and shore establishment photography.
Follow on X

The print featured in this article

Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.

HMS Utmost N19 U Class Submarine May 1942
HMS Utmost N19 U Class Submarine May 1942 Photo Print from £4.00 See sizes and prices

Leave a comment

Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Written by
Lee Edwards

Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.

More about Lee