HMS Inconstant (H49): Built for Turkey, Borrowed by Britain, Returned to Turkey
Built for the Turkish Navy
HMS Inconstant began life under an entirely different flag: she was laid down as TCG Muavenet for the Turkish Navy by Vickers-Armstrong at their Barrow-in-Furness shipyard on 24 May 1939, an I-class destroyer built to export specifications for a foreign customer.
The order she came from is worth understanding, because Turkey in the late 1930s was doing something quite deliberate. The Turkish republic had inherited almost nothing usable from the Ottoman navy and set about rebuilding one from European yards, ordering four modern destroyers from British yards in 1938. The design was a version of the Royal Navy's own I class, tweaked for the customer. Two of the four were finished and handed over before the war closed the door, and the other two, Muavenet and Gayret, were still on the slips at Barrow in September 1939 when the Admiralty simply bought them. They became HMS Inconstant and HMS Ithuriel. Turkey, needless to say, was not consulted in any meaningful sense; there was a war on, the ships were in a British yard, and that settled it.
With war looming, Britain purchased the still-unfinished destroyer in September 1939, requisitioning her for the Royal Navy in exactly the same way it had acquired several other foreign orders caught mid-construction as the international situation deteriorated.
Britain had done exactly this before, with consequences that ought to have given somebody pause. In August 1914 the Admiralty seized two dreadnought battleships being completed in British yards for the Ottoman navy, ships that had been paid for in large part by public subscription across Turkey, with schoolchildren collecting money for them. They became HMS Erin and HMS Agincourt, whose stories are in the articles on HMS Erin (1911) and HMS Agincourt (1913). Germany promptly offered the Ottomans two cruisers in their place, the offence was still fresh, and within three months Turkey was in the war on the German side, which cost Britain Gallipoli, three years of a Middle Eastern campaign and a great deal else. The Navy did the same thing to Brazil's destroyer order in 1939, as the article on HMS Havant (H32) describes. The difference in 1939 was that the Foreign Office had learned something: Turkey was neutral, courted by both sides, and sat on the straits into the Black Sea, so this time the ships were formally taken on loan and everybody was very careful to say so.
She was launched on 24 February 1941 and commissioned on 24 January 1942, an I-class destroyer displacing 1,370 long tons standard and armed with four 4.7-inch guns alongside torpedo tubes and depth charge equipment.
Madagascar and the Mediterranean
HMS Inconstant's first taste of real operations came that March, when she joined the covering force for Arctic convoys PQ12 and QP8 between Iceland and northern Russia, standing by alongside battleships, carriers and cruisers specifically watching for a sortie by the German battleship Tirpitz, a ship whose shadow loomed over almost every Arctic convoy of the war.
Her first operation was rather more exciting than standing by, because on that particular occasion Tirpitz actually came out. It is the only time in the entire war that she sortied against a convoy. Acting on a spotter aircraft report, she left Faettenfjord on 5 March 1942 with Admiral Ciliax aboard and three destroyers, and spent three days quartering the sea between Bear Island and the Norwegian coast looking for PQ 12 and QP 8. Bad weather, poor reconnaissance and a certain amount of luck meant that she and the convoys never found each other; at one point they passed within about eighty miles. On the way home she was found by torpedo bombers flown off HMS Victorious, which attacked and missed. Both convoys got through untouched. The consequence was out of all proportion to the event: Hitler, who had been thoroughly alarmed by how close his largest ship had come to being torpedoed, forbade any further attack on a convoy unless the escorting carrier had first been sunk or disabled, which is a condition no German admiral was ever going to be able to meet. Tirpitz spent the next two and a half years in a fjord being bombed. Inconstant was on her first job.
She went on to take part in the invasion of Madagascar that May, Operation Ironclad, escorting troop transports including the Duchess of Atholl, Sobieski and Winchester Castle, covering minesweeping operations ahead of the landings and engaging Vichy French shore batteries in support of the assault, part of the wider Allied effort to secure the strategically important island before Japanese forces operating in the Indian Ocean could make use of it.
Not every convoy went so smoothly. In June 1942 she escorted convoy MW11A from Haifa toward Malta as part of Operation Vigorous, an operation that ran into fierce Italian air and surface opposition; the cruiser HMS Hermione was torpedoed and sunk with the loss of 88 of her crew, and the convoy itself was eventually forced to turn back, a sharp reminder that not every Mediterranean operation of the period ended in success.
Operation Vigorous deserves the full arithmetic, because it is one of the bleakest sums of the Mediterranean war. Malta was starving, and in June 1942 the Admiralty tried to relieve it from both ends at once, sending Operation Harpoon east from Gibraltar with six merchant ships and Operation Vigorous west from Alexandria with eleven, in the hope that the Axis could not concentrate against both. The Axis concentrated against both. Harpoon lost four of its six and a destroyer, and two ships got into Grand Harbour. Vigorous ran into the Italian battle fleet coming down from Taranto, was ordered to turn back, turned round again, was bombed all day, and finally gave up and returned to Alexandria having lost the cruiser Hermione, three destroyers and several merchantmen, and delivered nothing at all. Seventeen merchant ships set out from the two ends of the Mediterranean and two of them reached Malta. It took Operation Pedestal in August, and the loss of nine merchantmen out of fourteen and an aircraft carrier, to keep the island in the war.
HMS Inconstant went on to a properly successful run as a submarine hunter in the year that followed, much of it under the command of Lieutenant Commander John Henry Eaden, DSC, who would go on to preside over both of her U-boat kills.
Sinking Two U-boats
HMS Inconstant, under Eaden's command, sank the German submarine U-409 in the Mediterranean, north-east of Algiers, on 12 July 1943, a solid individual success and a fitting piece of retribution: U-409 had herself sunk the 8,762-ton merchantman City of Venice only eight days earlier, in waters that remained remarkably dangerous for Allied shipping supporting the North African and Italian campaigns.
There is a thread running from that kill back to a convoy this site has covered elsewhere. The City of Venice, the ship U-409 sank eight days before Inconstant caught her, was not an ordinary merchantman: she was carrying 292 soldiers of the 1st Canadian Division to the invasion of Sicily as part of convoy KMS 18B, and six of them were killed. Two other ships of the same convoy were torpedoed in the same forty-eight hours, and fifty-eight Canadians died in that stretch of water without ever reaching the beach they had crossed an ocean for; the rescue work is described in the article on HMS Honeysuckle (K27). Sinking the boat responsible a week later is not justice in any meaningful sense, but the men in Inconstant knew perfectly well what they had been hunting and why.
She went on to further success on 18 June 1944, again under Eaden, sinking U-767 in the English Channel south-west of Guernsey, working alongside the destroyers HMS Fame and HMS Havelock in a coordinated attack that killed 49 of the submarine's crew for a single survivor. There was a certain grim satisfaction in it too: U-767 had herself sunk the frigate HMS Mourne with the loss of 111 lives only three days earlier, in the intensely busy weeks immediately following the D-Day landings, when Allied anti-submarine forces were working at full stretch protecting the invasion fleet and its supply lines.
The Channel in June 1944 was the most concentrated anti-submarine battle of the entire war, and it is worth saying why. Every ton of fuel, ammunition and food for the armies in Normandy went across a stretch of water about a hundred miles wide, in convoys running continuously, and the German navy threw everything it had left at it: some three dozen U-boats were ordered into the Channel from the Biscay ports within days of the landings, under orders to attack the invasion shipping regardless of loss. The Allied answer was to saturate the water with escort groups and aircraft. It worked, expensively. U-767 sank the frigate HMS Mourne on 15 June, and 111 men went with her; three days later Inconstant, Fame and Havelock caught U-767 south-west of Guernsey and killed forty-nine of her fifty-man crew. One man came out. That was the pattern all summer, on both sides, and it is the reason the build-up across the beaches was never seriously interrupted.
Returned to Her Original Name
HMS Inconstant was returned to Turkey on 9 March 1946, in a fitting piece of symmetry reverting to her originally intended name, Muavenet, the very identity she had been laid down under some seven years earlier before Britain's wartime requisition intervened.
Handing her back in 1946 was a piece of diplomacy as much as bookkeeping. Turkey had spent the war being courted by both sides and had stayed out of it until February 1945, when she declared war on Germany essentially in order to qualify for a seat at the United Nations. Britain wanted her friendly, and by 1946 there was an urgent new reason: Stalin was pressing Ankara for bases on the straits and for territory in the east, and the Turkish refusal to give way became one of the first confrontations of the Cold War, leading directly to the Truman Doctrine in 1947 and to Turkey joining NATO in 1952. Returning two destroyers that had been taken in 1939, under her original name and with a war record attached, was a very cheap way of making a point. Muavenet served the Turkish navy until 1960, which means that the ship laid down at Barrow in 1939 for one navy, fought by another, and handed to the first at last, gave twenty-one years of service between them.
She is a good argument against judging a warship by her fame. Inconstant was in commission for four years and two months. In that time she covered the only convoy Tirpitz ever came out to attack, put troops ashore in Madagascar, survived the worst-run convoy operation of the Mediterranean war, killed two U-boats under the same captain in two different oceans, and avenged, if that is the word, a Canadian troopship and a British frigate. Then she changed her name back and went home to a country she had never served. Most destroyers do less in twice the time.
She went on to serve the Turkish Navy for a further decade and a half under that name, before finally being discarded in 1960, closing out the career of a destroyer whose Royal Navy service, truly productive against German U-boats, had been bookended by two entirely different national flags.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.