Royal Navy

HMS Thrasher (N37): Two Bombs on the Casing and Two Victoria Crosses

15 November 2026 · 9 min read
HMS Thrasher (N37) T Class submarine seen broadside from her starboard side in 1943, trimmed low in choppy grey water with her pennant number painted on the conning tower and a shoreline of houses and a jetty crane behind
HMS Thrasher in 1943, trimmed so low that her casing barely clears the choppy grey water, with her pennant number painted large on the conning tower and a long shoreline of houses and a jetty crane behind her. Available as a restored photo print.

The Winnowing Flail

HMS Thrasher was ordered from Cammell Laird at Birkenhead on 4 September 1939, the day after Britain went to war, as one of the second group of T Class submarines. She was laid down on 14 November 1939, launched on 28 November 1940 and commissioned on 14 May 1941.

Her badge, approved by the Admiralty in January 1942, showed a golden sheaf of corn beneath two crossed flails, the ancient way of threshing and winnowing grain, and in Warship Week in March 1942 she was adopted by the people of Shoreditch in east London. The photograph shows her in 1943, after her return from the Mediterranean, trimmed down so far that the sea is lapping over her casing.

Stores for Malta and Soldiers from Crete

She sailed for the Mediterranean in June 1941 under Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Cowell, carrying stores to Malta on the way to join the 1st Submarine Flotilla at Alexandria. Her second patrol was not a hunting trip at all.

Crete had fallen in May, and hundreds of British and Commonwealth soldiers were still hiding in its hills. On the night of 26 July she tried to land a naval officer by folding canoe, but the weather was too rough; the next night the wind dropped and he got ashore.

On the night of 27 July a signal told her that men would be waiting at Limni Bay, and in the small hours she took aboard sixty-two British soldiers, five naval ratings and eleven Greeks. With seventy-eight extra men crammed into her there was no question of carrying on with the patrol, and she went straight back to Alexandria.

The rest of 1941 was hard and often frustrating. Off Cape Sunion in August four torpedoes missed a small German transport, and off Benghazi in September two convoy attacks with three and then five torpedoes went wide.

She sank caiques and schooners with her gun, and in October, under her new captain, Lieutenant Hugh Mackenzie, she sank the Italian schooner Esperia off Benghazi after letting the crew row ashore. Her first real success came on 25 November, when she torpedoed and sank the Italian armed merchant cruiser Attilio Deffenu, escorting a convoy into Brindisi.

On 10 January 1942 she sank the 5,000-ton transport Fedora north-east of Cape Dukato.

Two Bombs off Suda Bay

On 16 February 1942, north of Crete, Mackenzie attacked a deeply laden merchant ship off Suda Bay. She had five escorts, one ahead, one on each beam and one on each quarter, with aircraft circling overhead. Thrasher fired four torpedoes from two thousand yards.

Seconds after the first had gone a muffled explosion shook the whole boat, almost certainly a bomb, and machine gun bullets were heard striking the water above. Two further explosions followed.

She went down to 270 feet and over the next hour the escorts dropped thirty-three depth charges, most of them, Mackenzie wrote, too close for comfort. The citations for the awards that followed say she sank her target, but post-war study of German and Italian records identifies the ship as the transport Arkadia and shows that all four torpedoes missed.

Thrasher surfaced after dark and began to roll in the swell, and the crew heard something heavy banging about on the casing above them. At ten to two in the morning on 17 February they found a large hole in the side of the gun platform and an unexploded bomb of about a hundred pounds lying on the fore casing, held from rolling off only by what was left of its tail.

Mackenzie went full speed astern, trimming the bows down so that the first bomb could be slid over into the sea. Then a second bomb was found. It had come through the casing and was lying on the pressure hull itself, inside the narrow space between the outer casing and the hull, just forward of the gun.

The first lieutenant, Lieutenant Peter Roberts, and the second coxswain, Petty Officer Thomas Gould, went in after it. The only way to it was through a hinged grating some twenty feet away, and the space between casing and hull was so low that they had to crawl on their stomachs.

Gould lay on his back with the bomb in his arms while Roberts, lying in front of him, pulled him along by the shoulders, with only a torch to see by.

Every time the bomb moved, the citation says, there was "a loud twanging noise as of a broken spring which added nothing to their peace of mind." They were close to an enemy coast where patrols were active day and night, and both men knew that if an enemy ship appeared Mackenzie would have to dive, and they would drown where they lay.

It took forty minutes to work the bomb out through the grating, wrap it in a sack and drop it over the bows, and by half past three it was gone.

Mackenzie's patrol report did no more than commend the two men for their "excellent conduct", and he was, he recalled, "shaken" months later to hear that both had been awarded the Victoria Cross. The Honours and Awards Committee in London had objected that the deed was not done in the presence of the enemy, as the regulations required, and suggested the George Cross.

Admiral Sir Andrew Cunningham, who had made the recommendation, replied that two large enemy bombs in a submarine off an enemy coast were quite enough enemy presence. The awards were gazetted on 9 June 1942, and Thrasher became the only British submarine of the war to have two Victoria Crosses among her crew.

Benghazi, Tobruk and the Aegean

Through 1942 Thrasher was one of the most successful boats at Alexandria. Off Benghazi on 9 April she sank the transport Gala, and on 13 April the German army cargo ship Atlas, finishing off a small lighter with her gun the same day; a few days later a gun action with a German landing barge off Derna had to be broken off when it fired back.

In May she sank the transport Penelope off Monopoli in the Adriatic, and in June the Sant Antonio in the Gulf of Sirte. On 29 June, north of Tobruk, a signal moved her into the path of a fast ship reported on passage, a success later credited to the codebreakers.

Mackenzie, watching her come straight towards him at high speed, thought she must be carrying a very important cargo. She was the Italian sloop Diana, bound from Messina for Tobruk, and she sank quickly after Thrasher fired six torpedoes from six hundred yards.

The Italian hospital ship Arno and German motor torpedo boats picked up 146 survivors, but 336 were lost.

A month later, leaving Port Said for patrol on the evening of 26 July, she was attacked in error by a Fleet Air Arm Swordfish of 815 Squadron, which took her for an enemy submarine and dropped four depth charges. She limped back into harbour and spent a month under repair.

Mackenzie, now with the DSO, took her back to sea in September and sank the transport Padenna north of Tobruk, then went into the Aegean in October, where he sank a Greek schooner off Mount Athos and, on 20 October, the Italian naval auxiliary Lero between Symi and Rhodes.

In November she sailed for home, calling at Malta on the way with stores, torpedoes and passengers, and went into Chatham for a long refit.

Towing X5 to the Tirpitz

When she came out in May 1943 she was commanded by Lieutenant-Commander Arthur Hezlet, and that summer she was chosen as one of the six towing submarines for Operation Source, the midget submarine attack on the German battleship Tirpitz in northern Norway. She left Loch Cairnbawn on 11 September with the midget X5 on the end of a long tow, alongside Stubborn, Sceptre, Truculent, Syrtis and Sea Nymph.

The tow went well, and on 19 September the operational crew under Lieutenant Henty Henty-Creer of the RNVR changed places with the passage crew. On the evening of 20 September, off the entrance to the fjords, the tow and telephone line were disconnected and X5 slipped away towards Soroy Sound.

Thrasher never saw her again. When she came to the rendezvous afterwards no midget submarine appeared, and on 29 September she turned for home. Wreckage of X5 was later found near the entrance to the fjord where Tirpitz was lying, but what part, if any, she played in the attack is still not known.

Agents, Junks and Coasters

After a refit at her builders in 1944 Thrasher went out to the Far East under Lieutenant-Commander Michael Ainslie, and by January 1945 she was patrolling from Trincomalee off the coasts of Siam and Burma. The big Japanese ships had largely gone, and her targets were junks, sailing vessels and small motor coasters, which she sank in numbers with her gun, usually after a warning shot to let the crews get clear.

On 21 January she searched the islands off Siam for American airmen reported missing two days earlier, but found no trace of them.

Much of her work now was secret. On 9 March 1945, in Operation Copyright, she launched three canoes north of Phuket carrying a beach reconnaissance party of six, two Royal Marines officers, a Royal Engineers major, an RAF flight lieutenant and two others, to survey possible landing beaches.

For five nights she waited and searched near the rendezvous, but they never came back. On 22 March she met Torbay, then slipped in between the Sembilan Islands as a storm came on and collected four men from Lalang Island in forty-nine minutes.

In April she landed a party on Kamorta in the Nicobar Islands, and on 30 April, having badly underestimated the spring tide in the Mergui Archipelago, she spent an uncomfortable afternoon stemming a three-knot current before landing six men on Parker Island that night.

Her last fight came on 27 July 1945 off Langkawi, at the northern end of the Malacca Strait. In a single day she sank four wooden motor coasters, one after another as they crept along the shore, and then a motor schooner whose crew of nine were brought aboard while her earlier prisoners, already questioned, were put into the schooner's boat and sent on their way.

She came home after the war, was decommissioned in November 1945 and was broken up at Briton Ferry in 1947.

Only one of her own crew is on the roll of honour. Able Seaman James Choulerton of Sale in Manchester, aged twenty-six, drowned in Wallasey Dock at Birkenhead on 28 May 1944 while she was refitting at the yard that had built her.

Follow @Hantsprints on X for more Royal Navy history and warship, submarine and shore establishment photography.
Follow on X

The print featured in this article

Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.

HMS Thrasher N37 T Class Submarine 1943
HMS Thrasher N37 T Class Submarine 1943 Photo Print from £4.00 See sizes and prices

Leave a comment

Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Written by
Lee Edwards

Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.

More about Lee