HMS Truant (N68): Sinking the Karlsruhe, Blowing Up a Train and Two Dud Hits on a Japanese Cruiser
The Boy with the Fishing Rod
HMS Truant was built by Vickers-Armstrongs at Barrow-in-Furness as one of the first group of T Class submarines, launched on 5 May 1939 and accepted from the yard on 30 October 1939. Her name gave her one of the most cheerful badges in the submarine service: a truant schoolboy in a pink shirt, blue trousers and a wide straw hat, walking off with a fishing rod over his shoulder and his catch of fish in his hand.
In Warship Week in February 1942 she was adopted by Gosport, home of the submarine service. The photograph shows her in calm coastal water with five men gathered on the forward casing, her paintwork streaked by hard service.
The Karlsruhe
Truant's first success came in March 1940, when she sank the German merchant ship Edmund Hugo Stinnes 4 off the coast of Jutland. On 9 April, the day Germany invaded Denmark and Norway, she was off Kristiansand under Lieutenant-Commander Christopher Hutchinson.
German troops had landed there that morning, and in the early evening three torpedo boats came racing past, followed by a cruiser heading out to sea. She was the light cruiser Karlsruhe, part of the force that had brought the invasion to Kristiansand.
At four minutes to seven Hutchinson fired a full bow salvo of ten torpedoes from 4,500 yards. One of them hit Karlsruhe in the stern, wrecking her steering and engines and leaving her helpless.
The escorts came for Truant at once. Over the next four and a half hours they dropped thirty-one depth charges, most of them, the patrol report says, unpleasantly close, and she went as deep as three hundred feet to get away.
When she surfaced near midnight she was too badly damaged to stay on patrol and turned for Rosyth. Karlsruhe could not be saved, and that evening the Germans sank her with two torpedoes from the torpedo boat Greif.
Her bad luck that spring was not finished. Sailing again on 24 April to carry arms to Norwegian forces fighting north of Bergen, she was shaken by a mine explosion early the next morning and had to turn back to dock at Rosyth.
In July, off Norway, she was a day late leaving her area and the British submarine HMS Clyde, quite rightly expecting U-boats there, fired a full salvo of six torpedoes at her. All of them missed.
A Captured Prize in Biscay
Under her new captain, Lieutenant-Commander Hugh Haggard, she sailed for the Mediterranean at the end of August 1940. On the way, on 3 September, three hundred miles out in the Bay of Biscay, she stopped a heavily laden merchant ship heading for Bordeaux.
As Truant's gun trained on her bridge, the crew took to the boats and two explosions blew holes in her side. She was the Norwegian Tropic Sea, captured by the German raider Orion in the Pacific, with a German prize crew aboard taking her and her eight thousand tons of wheat to France.
She also had on board twenty-two survivors from the British ship Haxby. Haggard took the Haxby men aboard, with the Norwegian captain and his wife, and was discussing whether the Norwegian could get his ship under way again when she suddenly listed and sank in two minutes.
Haggard in the Mediterranean
From Malta Haggard made Truant one of the most dangerous boats in the Mediterranean. On 22 September 1940 she sank the 8,459-ton Provvidenza off Ischia, in the Bay of Naples.
In December, off Calabria, she sank the Sebastiano Bianchi, and three nights later followed what looked like a liner and her destroyer escort, until Haggard saw that the "destroyer" was a large laden tanker. Two torpedoes into her at close range sent the 8,177-ton Bonzo down very quickly.
In April 1941 she sank the patrol vessel Vanna by gunfire, and on 21 April she lay off Tripoli as the beacon submarine to guide in the battleships of the Mediterranean Fleet, including Warspite, for their bombardment of the port.
In May she sank the passenger ship Bengasi off Sardinia, and on the way out to Gibraltar seized the Vichy French merchant ship Gallium, only to have her taken back the same night by a French torpedo boat with four submarines in company.
That summer she crossed the Atlantic for a refit at the Portsmouth Navy Yard in New Hampshire, months before the United States entered the war. She was back in the Mediterranean by October, and on 23 October sank the transport Virginia S. in the Strait of Otranto.
Four nights later, off Senigallia on the Adriatic coast, she launched a folding canoe with Lieutenant R. Wilson of the Royal Artillery and Marine W. Hughes of the commando force Layforce. They paddled ashore and laid a charge on the railway line a hundred and fifty yards from the beach.
A southbound electric train came along, sounded its whistle and seemed about to stop, but at half past two there was a great yellow flash behind the engine and the locomotive was derailed. Both men got back to Truant, though the canoe capsized alongside and some of their gear went to the bottom.
On 31 October she sank the water tanker Meteor off Ortona, and in December, off Crete, her torpedoes hit the Italian torpedo boat Alcione in the stern, killing twenty, and she was run ashore and lost.
Bali and the Malacca Strait
Early in 1942 Truant was sent east in the desperate weeks after Japan entered the war, joining the Allied submarines in the Dutch East Indies. On the night of 24 February, north of Bali, she found a Japanese invasion convoy and fired six torpedoes from twelve hundred yards at its escorting flagship, the light cruiser Nagara.
Two dull thuds were heard against the hull, but neither torpedo exploded. On 1 April, in the Malacca Strait under Lieutenant-Commander Edward Balston, formerly of Tribune, a mistake in the firing drill sent all six torpedoes of a salvo at the same ship instead of three at each of two.
One hit, and she began to settle. When a second ship went alongside to help, Truant fired two more torpedoes, one of which hit her own ballast tank as it left the tube while the other sank the second ship in minutes. The two transports, the Yae Maru and the Shunsei Maru, went down within four minutes of each other.
Haggard, now with the DSO, took her back and in July damaged a Japanese army cargo ship with gunfire in the Malacca Strait. She came home round the Cape in late 1942.
Her only name on the roll of honour comes from this time: Leading Stoker John Ellis, aged thirty-five, from Wales, whose wife Mona lived in Barrow, died in Colombo on 2 August 1942 after an accidental fall.
Training Boat and Test Bed
Like Trident and Thrasher, she was by then a veteran, and after a refit at Troon she spent the rest of the war training crews and hunters at home, with one passage out to Malta and back in 1944. In 1945, under Lieutenant-Commander Russell Brookes, she carried out trials on the Clyde with an experimental snort mast, the breathing tube that let a submarine run her diesels at periscope depth.
She was decommissioned at Portsmouth in November 1945 and sold for scrap, but she never reached the breakers. She was wrecked while under tow to them in December 1946.
You Might Also Like
The print featured in this article
Every print is made to order in the UK, with free UK delivery.
Lee writes the ship histories and fleet features for Hampshire Prints. He served in the Royal Navy, and some of the modern fleet photographs on this site are his own, taken from the Portsmouth shoreline.
More about Lee

Leave a comment
Do you or your family have a connection to her? Share your memories below; we read every one.